As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
- Best overall: MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5
- Best budget: MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch
- Best premium: EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5
- Best for Xbox hockey fans: EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S
- MLB The Show 25 has the broader platform lineup, including PlayStation, Xbox and Nintendo Switch.
- NHL 25 is the focused pick for hockey fans and runs on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.
- Choose the version that matches your console before comparing editions or Black Friday listings.
- MLB The Show 25 offers Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines modes.
NHL 25 vs MLB The Show 25 Black Friday 2026 comes down to one big question: do you want fast, physical hockey or a deep baseball season you can shape over time? I researched and compared specs, reviews and owner feedback to map out the strongest console versions for each kind of sports fan. Black Friday falls on November 27, 2026, so this guide focuses on picking the right game and platform before shopping.
MLB The Show 25 is the flexible choice, with versions for PlayStation, Xbox and Nintendo Switch. NHL 25 is the current-generation hockey option for PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S. Here’s the bottom line: match the game to your sport, then match the version to your console. The picks below explain who each edition suits, what stands out and what to check before you buy.
How We Picked
- Platform compatibility: We prioritized accurate console matching, including current- and previous-generation options.
- Game modes: We compared headline modes and the kinds of play each title supports.
- Sports fit: We considered whether each game suits casual matches, career play or longer franchise-style sessions.
- Owner feedback and specs: We researched and compared published specifications, reviews and owner feedback rather than relying on a single feature.
- Black Friday usefulness: We selected versions that give shoppers clear options across consoles and play styles.
Comparison Table
| Product | Best for | Supported platform | Headline modes | Play format |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 | PS5 owners who want hockey | PlayStation 5 | 4: Franchise, Be A Pro, Hockey Ultimate Team, World of Chel | Console play |
| EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S | Xbox Series X|S hockey fans | Xbox Series X|S | 4: Franchise, Be A Pro, Hockey Ultimate Team, World of Chel | Console play |
| MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 | PS5 baseball fans who want variety | PlayStation 5 | 4: Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise, Storylines | Console play |
| MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S | Xbox Series owners who want baseball variety | Xbox Series X|S | 4: Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise, Storylines | Console play |
| MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch | Nintendo Switch owners and portable play | Nintendo Switch | 4: Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise, Storylines | 2: handheld and docked |
| MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 4 | PS4 owners who want a baseball game | PlayStation 4 | 4: Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise, Storylines | Console play |
| MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox One | Xbox One owners who want baseball | Xbox One | 4: Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise, Storylines | Console play |
Best Picks Reviewed
#1
EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5
The EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is the best hockey pick for PS5 owners who want a current-generation game built around 2 core ideas: responsive skating and physical play. The PS5 version focuses on NHL action without a last-generation platform split.
Best for: PS5 owners who want hockey
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- Core modes
- 4: Franchise, Be A Pro, Hockey Ultimate Team and World of Chel
- Generation
- 1 current-generation PlayStation console
- Built specifically for PS5
- Includes several distinct hockey modes
- A direct fit for NHL fans
- Not compatible with PS4
Is EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is worth considering for PS5 owners who want hockey, career play and online team modes in one game. The PS5 version is not compatible with PS4, so confirm the console before purchasing.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#2
EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S
The EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S is the best hockey pick for Xbox Series owners who want 4 recognizable modes, including Franchise, Be A Pro, Hockey Ultimate Team and World of Chel. The game targets the current Xbox generation.
Best for: Xbox Series X|S hockey fans
- Platform
- Xbox Series X|S
- Core modes
- 4: Franchise, Be A Pro, Hockey Ultimate Team and World of Chel
- Generation
- 1 current-generation Xbox family
- Designed for Xbox Series consoles
- Offers both career and team modes
- Strong match for dedicated hockey fans
- Not compatible with Xbox One
Is EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S is a solid pick for Xbox Series owners who want a dedicated hockey game and multiple play styles. Franchise, Be A Pro, Hockey Ultimate Team and World of Chel give players different ways to stay in the rink.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#3 · Top pick
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5
The MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is the best overall pick for baseball fans who want 4 major modes and a current-generation PlayStation version. Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines cover career, team-building and baseball-history play.
Best for: PS5 baseball fans who want variety
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- Core modes
- 4: Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines
- Generation
- 1 current-generation PlayStation console
- Four distinct headline modes
- Current-generation PlayStation version
- Supports several baseball play styles
- Not compatible with Xbox or Nintendo Switch
Is MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is a strong choice for PS5 owners who want career progression, roster management and baseball-themed stories. Four headline modes give the game broad appeal, while the platform-specific edition requires a PlayStation 5.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#4
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S
The MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S is the best current-generation baseball pick for Xbox owners who want 4 major modes in one package. Road to the Show and Franchise suit longer campaigns, while Diamond Dynasty and Storylines offer different goals.
Best for: Xbox Series owners who want baseball variety
- Platform
- Xbox Series X|S
- Core modes
- 4: Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines
- Generation
- 1 current-generation Xbox family
- Made for Xbox Series consoles
- Includes career and franchise play
- Offers several ways to play baseball
- Not compatible with Xbox One
Is MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S is worth a look for Xbox Series players seeking a full baseball package. The four headline modes cover career, franchise, collectible-team and story-focused play. Check that the listing names Xbox Series X|S.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#5
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch
The MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch is the best portable baseball pick for players who want 4 headline modes away from a television. The Switch version brings Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines to Nintendo’s hybrid console.
Best for: Nintendo Switch owners and portable play
- Platform
- Nintendo Switch
- Core modes
- 4: Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines
- Play format
- 2: handheld and docked
- Supports handheld and docked play
- Includes the main baseball modes
- Fits players who value portability
- Not compatible with PlayStation or Xbox
Is MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch is a good fit for baseball fans who value portable play. The game supports handheld and docked use and includes four headline modes. Choose another platform if you want to play on PlayStation or Xbox.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#6
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 4
The MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 4 is the best baseball option for PS4 owners who want 4 major modes without changing consoles. Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines provide career, team-building and story-driven choices.
Best for: PS4 owners who want a baseball game
- Platform
- PlayStation 4
- Core modes
- 4: Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines
- Generation
- 1 previous-generation PlayStation console
- Works on PlayStation 4
- Includes four headline modes
- Lets existing PS4 owners stay on their console
- Not a native PlayStation 5 edition
Is MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 4 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 4 is a practical choice for PS4 owners who want baseball without buying a new console. The game includes four major modes. PS5 owners should compare the PlayStation 5 listing before choosing a platform.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#7
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox One
The MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox One is the best baseball pick for Xbox One owners who want 4 headline modes on their existing console. Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines cover varied goals, from building a career to managing a team.
Best for: Xbox One owners who want baseball
- Platform
- Xbox One
- Core modes
- 4: Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines
- Generation
- 1 previous-generation Xbox family
- Compatible with Xbox One
- Offers career and franchise options
- Keeps existing Xbox One players in the series
- Not the Xbox Series X|S version
Is MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox One worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox One is a good match for players who want baseball on their current Xbox One console. Four headline modes add variety across career, team-building and story play. Confirm the exact platform in the listing.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
Which game is better for Black Friday 2026: NHL 25 or MLB The Show 25?
MLB The Show 25 supports more platforms, including Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One. Choose it for baseball, portable play or an older console. Choose NHL 25 for hockey on PlayStation 5 or Xbox Series X|S.
The games suit different fans. Compare platform, edition and included content before choosing the one you’ll play most.
Which consoles support NHL 25 and MLB The Show 25?
MLB The Show 25 supports PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Nintendo Switch. NHL 25 supports PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.
Check the platform on the product listing before ordering. A disc or download for one console family is not compatible with another.
What modes make MLB The Show 25 stand out?
MLB The Show 25 features Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines. Play a player career, build a roster, manage a team or explore baseball history. Check the listing for version-specific details and online requirements.
What should hockey fans know about NHL 25?
NHL 25 includes Franchise, Be A Pro, Hockey Ultimate Team and World of Chel. The modes cover team management, player careers, roster-building and online play. Confirm console compatibility, then choose a mode that matches how you want to play.
How do you choose the right Black Friday edition?
Start by matching the game to your sport and the edition to your console. MLB The Show 25 has versions for Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One and Xbox Series X|S. NHL 25 is available for PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.
Review the format, edition name and included content on the product listing before checkout.
Buying Guide
Match the game to your sport
Choose NHL 25 for hockey or MLB The Show 25 for baseball. Fans of both sports can base the decision on which game they expect to play most.
Confirm the console first
NHL 25 supports PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S. MLB The Show 25 also supports PlayStation 4, Xbox One and Nintendo Switch. Match the full platform name to your console.
Pick a mode that fits your time
Road to the Show and Be A Pro focus on player careers; Franchise centers on team management. Diamond Dynasty and Hockey Ultimate Team focus on roster-building, while World of Chel offers online play in NHL 25.
Compare listing details
Check the format, edition name, platform and included content on the retailer page. Keep the full product name handy when comparing listings.
Set up Black Friday shopping alerts
Save the exact product listing and compare retailers around November 27, 2026. Review shipping, return terms and seller details, and confirm the platform before ordering.
FAQ
Which game has more platform options, NHL 25 or MLB The Show 25?
MLB The Show 25 has more platform options. The game is available for PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Nintendo Switch. NHL 25 in this guide is for PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S, so check your console before choosing.
Can you play NHL 25 on PS4 or Xbox One?
No. The NHL 25 editions in this guide are for PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S. PlayStation 4 and Xbox One owners should not buy those versions expecting compatibility. MLB The Show 25 has editions for both PS4 and Xbox One.
Is MLB The Show 25 available on Nintendo Switch?
Yes. MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch brings the baseball game to Nintendo’s hybrid console, with handheld and docked play. Check that the retailer listing names Nintendo Switch, since PlayStation and Xbox editions do not run on the Switch.
What modes are included in MLB The Show 25?
MLB The Show 25 features Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, Franchise and Storylines as four headline modes. The group covers player career progression, roster building, team management and story-focused baseball. Check the platform listing for specific edition details before buying.
Which NHL 25 version should Xbox fans buy?
Xbox Series X|S owners should choose EA SPORTS NHL 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S. The game is not compatible with Xbox One. Check the full product name and console label on the listing to avoid choosing a different platform version.
When is Black Friday 2026?
Black Friday 2026 falls on November 27. Use the date to compare the exact NHL 25 or MLB The Show 25 platform listing you want. Check retailer terms, format and included content before completing an order.