As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
- Best overall: 2K NBA 2K26 for PlayStation 5
- Best budget: EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5
- Best premium: Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 26 for PlayStation 5
- Best for a familiar NBA entry: 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5
- EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 is the football pick, while 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 is the basketball pick.
- Both games focus on signature sports modes, team building, and head-to-head play, so choose by sport and preferred style.
- Newer series entries add current rosters and updated modes; older entries remain appealing for fans who want a familiar edition.
- Compare platform, local multiplayer, online requirements, and included modes before choosing a Black Friday 2026 game.
- The guide covers seven PlayStation 5 sports games, from football and basketball to baseball, wrestling, and soccer.
EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 is the stronger pick for football fans, while 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 suits basketball fans best. For Black Friday 2026, the right choice comes down to the sport you follow, the modes you play, and whether current rosters matter more than a familiar edition. We researched and compared specs, reviews and owner feedback to help make that call.
Here's the bottom line: both games offer a full sports-game experience, but they are not interchangeable. The products below add newer entries and other sports for shoppers building a holiday shortlist. Check each game's edition, online requirements, and included content before purchasing. Digital and physical versions can differ in availability and included bonuses.
How We Picked
- We prioritized seven PlayStation 5 sports games that cover football, basketball, baseball, wrestling, and soccer.
- We compared each game's central modes, sport-specific features, multiplayer options, and roster appeal.
- We used product specifications, published feature details, reviews, and owner feedback rather than detailed claims.
- We considered both familiar entries and newer series editions to give shoppers options across play styles.
- We favored products with clear reasons to choose them, such as a signature mode, recognizable league, or distinct sport.
Comparison Table
| Product | Best for | Platform | Main numerical detail | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 | NFL fans and Franchise players | PlayStation 5 | 32 NFL teams | BOOM Tech tackling |
| 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 | NBA fans and MyCAREER players | PlayStation 5 | 30 NBA teams | MyCAREER, MyTEAM, MyNBA |
| EA Sports Madden NFL 26 for PlayStation 5 | Players who prioritize newer NFL rosters | PlayStation 5 | 32 NFL teams | Franchise and Superstar |
| 2K NBA 2K26 for PlayStation 5 | Players who prioritize a newer NBA entry | PlayStation 5 | 30 NBA teams | 5-on-5 basketball |
| Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 26 for PlayStation 5 | Baseball fans | PlayStation 5 | 9 fielding positions | Batting, pitching, fielding |
| 2K WWE 2K26 for PlayStation 5 | Wrestling fans | PlayStation 5 | 1-on-1 and multi-person bouts | Sports entertainment |
| EA Sports FC 26 for PlayStation 5 | Soccer fans | PlayStation 5 | 11 players per side | Clubs and career modes |
Best Picks Reviewed
#1
EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5
The EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 is the best football pick for franchise players, with 32 NFL teams and BOOM Tech tackling.
Best for: NFL fans who want Franchise and head-to-head football
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- NFL teams
- 32
- Core modes
- Franchise, Superstar, Ultimate Team
- Signature feature
- BOOM Tech tackling
- Official NFL teams and presentation
- Franchise mode supports long-term team building
- BOOM Tech emphasizes physics-based tackling
- The annual-series format offers less appeal to players who skip yearly roster updates
Is EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 is worth considering for NFL fans who want 32 teams, Franchise, and BOOM Tech tackling. Choose it for football-focused play; choose a basketball title when NBA action is the priority.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#2
2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5
The 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 is the best basketball pick for NBA fans, with all 30 NBA teams and MyCAREER progression.
Best for: NBA fans who want MyCAREER and team-based basketball
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- NBA teams
- 30
- Core modes
- MyCAREER, MyTEAM, MyNBA
- Game format
- 5-on-5 basketball
- A broad mix of solo and team-building modes
- MyCAREER gives players a personal progression path
- NBA team presentation suits league followers
- Several modes focus on online play and connected features
Is 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 is worth buying for basketball fans who want 30 NBA teams and modes such as MyCAREER, MyTEAM, and MyNBA. Check online requirements for connected features before choosing an edition.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#3
EA Sports Madden NFL 26 for PlayStation 5
The EA Sports Madden NFL 26 for PlayStation 5 is the best newer football pick for roster-focused fans, with 32 NFL teams and a full Franchise mode.
Best for: Players who prefer a newer NFL roster and feature set
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- NFL teams
- 32
- Core modes
- Franchise, Superstar, Ultimate Team
- Sport
- American football
- Newer entry for players prioritizing current rosters
- Franchise gives solo players a long-term goal
- Multiple modes serve different types of NFL fans
- Players focused on a specific older edition should compare its features first
Is EA Sports Madden NFL 26 for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
EA Sports Madden NFL 26 for PlayStation 5 is a strong choice for NFL fans who prioritize a newer roster and established modes. Franchise, Superstar, and Ultimate Team give players several ways to engage with its 32-team league.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#4 · Top pick
2K NBA 2K26 for PlayStation 5
The 2K NBA 2K26 for PlayStation 5 is the best newer basketball pick for NBA followers, with 30 teams and a full 5-on-5 game format.
Best for: Basketball fans who want a newer NBA entry
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- NBA teams
- 30
- Game format
- 5-on-5 basketball
- Core modes
- MyCAREER, MyTEAM, MyNBA
- Newer series entry for current NBA fans
- Multiple modes cover career, team building, and franchise play
- Official NBA teams and player presentation
- Connected modes require attention to online access and account terms
Is 2K NBA 2K26 for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
2K NBA 2K26 for PlayStation 5 is a strong fit for NBA fans who want a newer entry, all 30 teams, and career or franchise modes. Compare the edition details and online requirements before selecting a version.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#5
Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 26 for PlayStation 5
The Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 26 for PlayStation 5 is the best baseball pick for season and career fans, with 9 defensive positions on the field.
Best for: Baseball fans who enjoy season, career, and diamond action
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- Fielding positions
- 9
- Sport
- Major League Baseball
- Play style
- Batting, pitching, and fielding
- A focused baseball option among the sports titles
- Batting, pitching, and fielding create varied play
- Career and season modes support different session lengths
- The Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 26 for PlayStation 5's baseball focus is less appealing to shoppers seeking multiple sports
Is Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 26 for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 26 for PlayStation 5 is worth considering for baseball fans who want batting, pitching, fielding, and career or season play. The nine-position field adds the full defensive structure of the sport.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#6
2K WWE 2K26 for PlayStation 5
The 2K WWE 2K26 for PlayStation 5 is the best wrestling pick for sports-entertainment fans, with 1-on-1 matches and multi-person bouts.
Best for: Wrestling fans who want match variety and custom play
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- Match formats
- 1-on-1 and multi-person
- Sport style
- Sports entertainment
- Play focus
- Matches and roster management
- Wrestling gives the category a distinct alternative to team sports
- Match formats support solo and group play
- A fit for fans who enjoy spectacle and character rosters
- The rules and presentation differ from traditional league sports
Is 2K WWE 2K26 for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
2K WWE 2K26 for PlayStation 5 is a good pick for wrestling fans who want 1-on-1 bouts, multi-person matches, and sports-entertainment presentation. Choose another game when realistic league competition matters more than wrestling spectacle.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#7
EA Sports FC 26 for PlayStation 5
The EA Sports FC 26 for PlayStation 5 is the best soccer pick for club and international football fans, with 11 players per side on the pitch.
Best for: Soccer fans who want club, career, and head-to-head play
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- Players per side
- 11
- Sport
- Association football
- Play focus
- Matches, clubs, and career modes
- Soccer is a strong alternative to North American sports
- Team play suits both solo sessions and head-to-head matches
- Career-focused modes add longer-term goals
- Players who do not follow soccer get less value from its league focus
Is EA Sports FC 26 for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
EA Sports FC 26 for PlayStation 5 is worth considering for soccer fans who want 11-player sides, club play, and career-focused modes. The game centers on association football, so choose it for soccer rather than NFL or NBA action.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
Which is better on PS5: Madden 25 or NBA 2K25?
EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 suits NFL fans; 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 suits NBA fans. If you follow both leagues, compare the modes you will play most.
Madden focuses on NFL teams, Franchise, Superstar, and BOOM Tech tackling. NBA 2K centers on NBA teams, MyCAREER, MyTEAM, and MyNBA. For group play, check local multiplayer support and controller needs. For solo play, compare career and franchise modes.
What is the main difference between Madden NFL 25 and NBA 2K25?
EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 features 32 NFL teams and American football; 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 features 30 NBA teams and five-on-five basketball. Their sports drive different pacing, controls, and modes.
Madden emphasizes play calling, field position, passing, and tackling. NBA 2K emphasizes possessions, spacing, shooting, and defense. Check online requirements and edition contents before buying. Choose Madden for football strategy and roster management, or NBA 2K for basketball and player-focused career play.
Should I buy the older sports game or a newer entry?
EA Sports Madden NFL 26 for PlayStation 5 and 2K NBA 2K26 for PlayStation 5 are newer entries; Madden NFL 25 and NBA 2K25 offer their own modes and rosters. Choose by features, not release order.
Current rosters or new features can favor a newer entry; a previous release can suit players who prefer its modes. Check online support, edition contents, and console compatibility. Core editions suit players who want matches without added content.
Which PS5 sports game is best for local multiplayer?
EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5, 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5, and EA Sports FC 26 for PlayStation 5 offer familiar team matchups. Player limits vary by mode, so check the listing before planning a group session.
Madden suits NFL fans, NBA 2K suits basketball fans, and FC suits soccer fans. WWE 2K26 adds wrestling. Check controller needs and local player support; remote play has separate internet and account requirements.
What should I check before buying a PS5 sports game on Black Friday?
Before buying, confirm the full product name, PlayStation 5 compatibility, edition, included modes, and online requirements. Check whether the listing is for a disc or digital copy, and review bonus content and account requirements.
For a gift, match the sport and age rating to the recipient. Compare roster and mode preferences with games they already own. Keep the receipt and check the retailer’s return policy.
Buying Guide
Start with the sport you actually follow
Choose EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 for NFL play, 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 for NBA action, Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 26 for PlayStation 5 for baseball, or EA Sports FC 26 for PlayStation 5 for soccer.
Match the mode to your play style
Compare the exact mode list for your edition. Check account and internet requirements for connected play.
Compare older and newer series entries
Prioritize the roster, modes, and features you want. Check product descriptions rather than assuming annual releases include the same content.
Check multiplayer and console compatibility
Confirm local player support, remote-play requirements, and PlayStation 5 compatibility. Check the format and controller needs before buying.
FAQ
Madden 25 PS5 vs NBA 2K25 PS5: which game should I buy?
EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 is the pick for NFL fans, while 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 is the pick for NBA fans. Compare Franchise, Superstar, MyCAREER, and MyTEAM to find the modes you will play most.
Is Madden NFL 25 on PS5 a good game for Franchise mode?
EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 is a strong Franchise choice for NFL fans who enjoy managing a team over time. The game includes 32 NFL teams, along with Superstar and Ultimate Team for players seeking other ways to play.
Is NBA 2K25 on PS5 worth buying for MyCAREER?
2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 is a good fit for basketball fans who want a player-focused MyCAREER path. The game also includes MyTEAM and MyNBA, giving NBA followers career, team-building, and franchise options in one sports title.
What is the difference between NBA 2K25 and NBA 2K26 on PS5?
2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 and 2K NBA 2K26 for PlayStation 5 both focus on NBA basketball and include career and team modes. Choose the newer entry for its updated series features; choose the earlier one when its edition suits your preferences.
Can I play Madden NFL 25 and NBA 2K25 on PS5 offline?
EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 and 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 include modes suited to solo play, while connected features require online access. Check each game's current requirements for specific modes, accounts, and downloadable content before purchase.
Which sports game is best for PS5 multiplayer?
EA Sports Madden NFL 25 for PlayStation 5 is a strong multiplayer choice for NFL fans, while 2K NBA 2K25 for PlayStation 5 suits basketball fans. EA Sports FC 26 for PlayStation 5 adds soccer matchups; confirm local player limits for the mode you plan to use.