As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
- Best overall: Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S
- Best budget: Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for PC (Steam)
- Best premium: Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Deluxe Edition for Xbox Series X|S
- Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for PlayStation 5: Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox One
- Sea of Thieves is the stronger pick for crew-based pirate adventures, ship combat, and cross-platform play.
- Valheim suits players who want survival crafting, base building, and a shared world for up to 10 players.
- Sea of Thieves is available on Xbox, PlayStation 5, and PC; Valheim is available on Xbox and PC.
- Choose the platform edition your friends use before comparing Black Friday 2026 buying options.
Sea of Thieves and Valheim are 2 multiplayer adventures with very different reasons to rally a crew. Sea of Thieves turns the high seas into a shared playground of ship battles, treasure hunts, and pirate mischief. Valheim sends players into a perilous survival world built around exploration, crafting, and cooperative boss fights. I researched and compared specs, reviews and owner feedback to help you pick the right game for Black Friday 2026.
Here's the bottom line: choose Sea of Thieves for spontaneous nautical adventures with a crew of up to 4, or Valheim for a survival sandbox that supports up to 10 players. Both games reward teamwork, but their moment-to-moment rhythms are miles apart. The product picks below cover the main platform editions, so you can match a game to your hardware and the friends you plan to play with.
How We Picked
- Compared the core gameplay loop: pirate voyages and ship combat in Sea of Thieves versus survival, crafting, and building in Valheim.
- Checked supported platforms and multiplayer features to clarify where each edition fits.
- Prioritized clear group-size details, including Sea of Thieves crews of up to 4 and Valheim sessions of up to 10.
- Reviewed owner feedback and game details for replayability, accessibility, and the kind of time commitment each game encourages.
- Selected editions for Xbox, PlayStation 5, and PC so readers can match a game to their existing setup.
Comparison Table
| Product | Best for | Max group size | Platform | Play style |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S | Xbox pirate crews | Up to 4 | Xbox Series X|S | Pirate adventure |
| Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 | PlayStation 5 pirate crews | Up to 4 | PlayStation 5 | Pirate adventure |
| Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for PC (Steam) | PC pirate crews | Up to 4 | PC (Steam) | Pirate adventure |
| Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Deluxe Edition for Xbox Series X|S | Xbox players who want cosmetics | Up to 4 | Xbox Series X|S | Pirate adventure plus cosmetics |
| Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for PC (Steam) | PC survival and crafting fans | Up to 10 | PC (Steam) | Survival sandbox |
| Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox Series X|S | Xbox Series X|S survival groups | Up to 10 | Xbox Series X|S | Survival sandbox |
| Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox One | Xbox One survival groups | Up to 10 | Xbox One | Survival sandbox |
Best Picks Reviewed
#1 · Top pick
Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S
The Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S is the best console pick for Xbox crews, with 4-player ship crews and cross-platform multiplayer.
Best for: Xbox players who want lively co-op voyages
- Platform
- Xbox Series X|S
- Crew size
- 1–4 players
- Cross-play
- Xbox, PC, and PlayStation 5
- Edition
- 1 standard game edition
- Strong fit for co-op sessions and shared ship duties
- Cross-play connects players across supported platforms
- Exploration and voyages keep sessions varied
- Ship roles feel less rewarding when playing solo
Is the Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. The Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S is a strong buy for Xbox players who want lively co-op, cross-play, and pirate voyages. The Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S's 4-player crews make it an especially good match for a regular gaming group.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#2
Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for PlayStation 5
The Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is the best pick for PS5 pirate crews, with 4-player crews and cross-platform multiplayer.
Best for: PlayStation 5 players joining friends on other systems
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- Crew size
- 1–4 players
- Cross-play
- PlayStation 5, Xbox, and PC
- Edition
- 1 standard game edition
- Brings the pirate sandbox to PlayStation 5
- Cross-play helps friends meet across platform families
- Supports cooperative voyages and competitive encounters
- A PlayStation 5 console is required
Is the Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. The Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is worth a look for PS5 owners who want a social pirate adventure. Cross-play links its 4-player crews with supported Xbox and PC players, making it easier to join friends.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#3
Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for PC (Steam)
The Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for PC (Steam) is the best PC pick for pirate crews, with 4-player voyages and cross-platform multiplayer.
Best for: PC players who want flexible co-op sessions
- Platform
- PC (Steam)
- Crew size
- 1–4 players
- Cross-play
- PC, Xbox, and PlayStation 5
- Edition
- 1 standard game edition
- Supports cross-play with console friends
- Ship crews give each player a useful role
- Voyages mix exploration, combat, and treasure hunting
- Requires a compatible gaming PC and online access
Is the Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for PC (Steam) worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. The Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Standard Edition for PC (Steam) suits PC players who want co-op voyages with console-owning friends. The 4-player crew format makes teamwork central, while cross-play connects supported PC, Xbox, and PlayStation 5 players.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#4
Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Deluxe Edition for Xbox Series X|S
The Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Deluxe Edition for Xbox Series X|S is the best extra-cosmetics pick for Xbox pirates, with 4-player crews and bonus digital items.
Best for: Xbox players who want a style-focused edition
- Platform
- Xbox Series X|S
- Crew size
- 1–4 players
- Cross-play
- Xbox, PC, and PlayStation 5
- Edition
- 1 deluxe game edition
- Includes bonus digital cosmetic content
- Keeps the same core pirate adventure
- Supports cross-play with other platforms
- Bonus cosmetics do not change the core gameplay
Is the Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Deluxe Edition for Xbox Series X|S worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes, for Xbox players who value included digital cosmetics alongside the pirate adventure. The Xbox Game Studios Sea of Thieves Deluxe Edition for Xbox Series X|S retains the 4-player crew experience and cross-play, while its extras focus on appearance rather than new gameplay.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#5
Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for PC (Steam)
The Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for PC (Steam) is the best survival pick for PC crafting fans, with cooperative worlds supporting up to 10 players.
Best for: PC players who enjoy survival and building
- Platform
- PC (Steam)
- Player cap
- Up to 10 players
- Camera
- 3D third-person perspective
- Game type
- 1 survival sandbox
- Deep crafting and base-building loop
- Exploration rewards preparation and teamwork
- Large group cap supports shared-world play
- Progression and resource gathering take patience
Is the Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for PC (Steam) worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. The Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for PC (Steam) is a strong fit for players who enjoy crafting, exploration, and building a home base. The Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for PC (Steam)'s world supports up to 10 players, giving small groups plenty of room to tackle survival challenges together.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#6
Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox Series X|S
The Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox Series X|S is the best console survival pick for Xbox groups, with shared-world sessions for up to 10 players.
Best for: Xbox Series X|S players who want cooperative survival
- Platform
- Xbox Series X|S
- Player cap
- Up to 10 players
- Camera
- 3D third-person perspective
- Game type
- 1 survival sandbox
- Brings crafting and exploration to Xbox
- Supports large cooperative groups
- Base building gives the crew a shared goal
- Survival systems demand steady resource gathering
Is the Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox Series X|S worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. The Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox Series X|S is a good choice for console players who want a long-form survival adventure. Up to 10 players can share the cooperative experience, with crafting, exploration, and base building shaping the group’s progress.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#7
Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox One
The Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox One is the best older-Xbox pick for survival fans, with cooperative sessions supporting up to 10 players.
Best for: Xbox One players who want a shared survival world
- Platform
- Xbox One
- Player cap
- Up to 10 players
- Camera
- 3D third-person perspective
- Game type
- 1 survival sandbox
- Offers a console route into Valheim’s survival loop
- Supports group play for up to 10 players
- Exploration and construction offer long-term goals
- Older hardware owners should check current platform requirements
Is the Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox One worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. The Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox One suits players who want cooperative survival without moving to a newer Xbox console. The Coffee Stain Publishing Valheim for Xbox One's world supports up to 10 players, and the core appeal is the same blend of exploration, crafting, and shared building.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
Which game is better, Sea of Thieves or Valheim?
Sea of Thieves suits groups seeking lively voyages and pirate encounters. Valheim is better for players who enjoy survival, crafting, and long-term building.
Choose Sea of Thieves for action with a crew of up to 4. Choose Valheim for shared projects with up to 10 players.
How many players can play Sea of Thieves and Valheim?
Sea of Thieves supports crews of up to 4, with players sharing ship duties and combat. Valheim supports up to 10, letting groups gather, build, explore, and fight together.
Both games support cross-play across supported platforms. Check platform compatibility and online access before choosing.
Which game has better gameplay for co-op?
Sea of Thieves centers on voyages, ship teamwork, and improvised encounters. Valheim emphasizes gathering, crafting, shelter, exploration, and boss fights.
Pick Sea of Thieves for fast-moving crew adventures or Valheim for steady survival progress and base building.
Which platforms support Sea of Thieves and Valheim?
Sea of Thieves is available for Xbox, PlayStation 5, and PC. Valheim is available for Xbox and PC.
Check each store listing for device compatibility, including the correct Xbox edition. Cross-play works across supported platforms when players meet the game’s requirements.
Should you buy Sea of Thieves or Valheim on Black Friday 2026?
Choose Sea of Thieves for pirate voyages and ship combat, or Valheim for survival, exploration, and construction. Sea of Thieves Standard Edition includes the core adventure; Sea of Thieves Deluxe Edition adds digital cosmetics.
Before buying, match the game to your group size, platform, and preferred pace.
Buying Guide
Choose by your group’s preferred pace
Sea of Thieves delivers action-focused voyages for crews of up to 4. Valheim supports up to 10 players and rewards gathering, planning, and building.
Match the edition to your platform
Sea of Thieves is available for Xbox, PlayStation 5, and PC; Valheim is available for Xbox and PC. Confirm that your group can play on supported platforms.
Pick the right Sea of Thieves edition
Sea of Thieves Standard Edition includes the core adventure. Sea of Thieves Deluxe Edition adds digital cosmetics.
Check group size before buying Valheim
Valheim supports up to 10 players, with crafting, exploration, and shared base building for groups of any size.
Compare Black Friday 2026 options carefully
Choose an edition that fits your platform and group. Review the store listing to confirm included content and compatibility.
FAQ
Is Sea of Thieves better than Valheim for multiplayer?
Sea of Thieves is better for small crews who want ship-based action, while Valheim suits larger groups who enjoy survival and crafting. Sea of Thieves supports up to 4 crew members; Valheim supports up to 10 players. Choose based on your group size and preferred pace.
Can you play Sea of Thieves with friends on different platforms?
Yes. Sea of Thieves supports cross-play among supported Xbox, PC, and PlayStation 5 versions. A crew can include players on different platform families, making the game a strong pick when friends own different systems. Each player still needs access to a compatible edition and online play.
How many people can play Valheim together?
Valheim supports cooperative sessions for up to 10 players. Groups can explore, gather resources, craft gear, build a base, and face challenging encounters together. Check the platform edition and current multiplayer requirements so every player in your group can join the same world.
Is Valheim available on Xbox One and Xbox Series X|S?
Yes. Valheim has Xbox editions for Xbox One and Xbox Series X|S. Choose the edition that matches your console, then check the current store listing for compatibility and online-play details. Both versions center on cooperative survival, crafting, exploration, and building.
What is included in Sea of Thieves Deluxe Edition?
Sea of Thieves Deluxe Edition includes the core pirate adventure plus digital cosmetic extras. The added items focus on appearance rather than a separate campaign or different crew size. Players still get the same core voyages and 4-player crew experience as the standard edition.
Should I buy Sea of Thieves or Valheim for Black Friday 2026?
Buy Sea of Thieves for pirate voyages, ship combat, and co-op crews of up to 4. Choose Valheim for survival crafting, exploration, and shared worlds for up to 10 players. Check your group’s platform and preferred play style before selecting an edition.