As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
- Best overall: Square Enix Live A Live Remake for Nintendo Switch
- Best budget: Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PC
- Best premium: Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 5
- Best for local co-op: Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PlayStation 4
- Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake is the better match for real-time combat and up to 3-player local co-op.
- Square Enix Live A Live Remake offers 8 distinct story scenarios and turn-based tactical battles.
- Choose the game by play style first: action and co-op versus story variety and strategy.
- Platform availability differs, so match each edition to the player’s console or PC before buying.
Secret of Mana and Live A Live are both Square Enix RPG remakes, but they deliver very different adventures. Secret of Mana puts a party of 3 heroes into real-time action and supports up to 3 local players. Live A Live builds its journey around 8 separate stories, each with a distinct setting and turn-based combat. The better pick depends on whether you want cooperative action or a story-driven solo RPG.
For this Black Friday 2026 guide, I researched and compared specs, reviews and owner feedback across the available game editions. The listings below cover the PlayStation and PC versions of Secret of Mana, plus Nintendo Switch, PlayStation and PC editions of Live A Live. Here's the bottom line: pick by platform and play style, then check the edition details before checkout.
How We Picked
- Compared each game’s core combat, story structure and player count.
- Included platform editions that suit console and PC players.
- Prioritized clear differences that help shoppers choose between the two remakes.
- Reviewed published game details alongside owner feedback and edition information.
- Considered replay value, co-op options and the kind of RPG experience each game offers.
Comparison Table
| Product | Best for | Players | Distinct stories or heroes | Combat style |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PlayStation 4 | Local co-op | 1–3 local | 3 heroes | Real-time action |
| Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PC | Desktop action RPG play | 1–3 local | 3 heroes | Real-time action |
| Square Enix Live A Live Remake for Nintendo Switch | Portable story variety | 1 | 8 scenarios | Turn-based |
| Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 5 | Solo console RPG play | 1 | 8 scenarios | Turn-based |
| Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 4 | PS4 story RPG fans | 1 | 8 scenarios | Turn-based |
| Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PC | Desktop strategy RPG play | 1 | 8 scenarios | Turn-based |
Secret of Mana vs Live A Live Remake Black Friday Deals 2026
#1
Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PlayStation 4
The Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PlayStation 4 is the best action RPG pick for couch co-op fans, with support for up to 3 local players.
Best for: PlayStation 4 players who want action and local co-op
- Local players
- 1–3
- Playable heroes
- 3
- Genre
- Action RPG
- Real-time combat keeps battles lively.
- Three-player local co-op is a standout feature.
- A familiar fantasy adventure with an updated presentation.
- The remake’s presentation differs from the original’s visual style.
Is the Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PlayStation 4 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
The Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PlayStation 4 is worth buying for players who want a cooperative action RPG. The Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PlayStation 4's 3-player local co-op makes it an especially strong pick for friends or family sharing one screen.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#2
Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PC
The Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PC is the best desktop RPG pick for players who want real-time fantasy combat and a party of 3 heroes.
Best for: PC players who want a classic-style action RPG
- Playable heroes
- 3
- Genre
- Action RPG
- Perspective
- 3D
- Real-time battles reward active movement.
- The three-character party gives players different roles.
- A good fit for fans of classic fantasy adventures.
- The adventure focuses on one central story.
Is the Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PC worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
The Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for PC is worth buying for desktop players who prefer action over turn-based battles. The 3-hero party and fast combat provide a focused adventure, while the story follows a single main journey.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#3 · Top pick
Square Enix Live A Live Remake for Nintendo Switch
The Square Enix Live A Live Remake for Nintendo Switch is the best portable story RPG for players who want 8 distinct scenarios in one game.
Best for: Nintendo Switch players who enjoy varied stories
- Story scenarios
- 8
- Players
- 1
- Genre
- Turn-based RPG
- Eight settings create a varied campaign.
- Portable play suits its chapter-based structure.
- HD-2D visuals give the adventure a distinctive look.
- The game is designed for solo play.
Is the Square Enix Live A Live Remake for Nintendo Switch worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
The Square Enix Live A Live Remake for Nintendo Switch is worth buying for solo RPG fans who want variety in a portable format. The Square Enix Live A Live Remake for Nintendo Switch's 8 scenarios shift between different eras, characters and battle situations, keeping the campaign fresh.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#4
Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 5
The Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 5 is the best console pick for players seeking 8 story arcs and strategic turn-based battles.
Best for: PlayStation 5 players who want a single-player RPG
- Story scenarios
- 8
- Players
- 1
- Combat style
- Turn-based
- Eight scenarios offer different narrative flavors.
- Battles reward positioning and planning.
- HD-2D presentation blends pixel art and 3D effects.
- No local co-op or multiplayer mode.
Is the Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
The Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 5 is worth buying for players after a solo RPG with strong story variety. The Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 5's 8 scenarios and tactical turn-based encounters make it a better fit for thoughtful play than group co-op.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#5
Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 4
The Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 4 is the best previous-generation console pick for solo players who want 8 different story scenarios.
Best for: PlayStation 4 owners who enjoy narrative RPGs
- Story scenarios
- 8
- Players
- 1
- Combat style
- Turn-based
- A complete RPG experience built around 8 chapters.
- Distinct settings help keep the narrative moving.
- Tactical combat gives battles a deliberate pace.
- The single-player structure is not suited to co-op fans.
Is the Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 4 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
The Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PlayStation 4 is worth buying for PS4 owners who want a solo RPG with multiple story styles. The 8 scenarios provide a varied campaign, and turn-based battles suit players who enjoy careful decisions.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#6
Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PC
The Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PC is the best desktop strategy RPG for solo players who want 8 separate tales and turn-based combat.
Best for: PC players who value story variety
- Story scenarios
- 8
- Players
- 1
- Combat style
- Turn-based
- Eight storylines bring different settings and themes.
- Strategic battles reward thoughtful positioning.
- HD-2D art gives the game a clear visual identity.
- The game offers no multiplayer mode.
Is the Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PC worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
The Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PC is worth buying for desktop players who want a solo, story-led RPG. The Square Enix Live A Live Remake for PC's 8 scenarios and turn-based combat create a varied experience that rewards attention to both narrative and battle strategy.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
Which remake is better: Secret of Mana or Live A Live?
Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake is better for real-time action and up to 3-player local co-op, while Square Enix Live A Live Remake is better for 8 varied solo stories. The combat difference is the quickest way to choose. Secret of Mana asks players to move, attack and manage a team during active battles. Live A Live pauses for tactical, turn-based decisions.
The stories also have different shapes. Secret of Mana follows a central fantasy adventure. Live A Live connects 8 separate scenarios, each with its own time period, characters and tone. Worth it for most players depends on what kind of session they want: shared action with friends, or an episodic solo journey.
Which game is better for multiplayer and couch co-op?
Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake is the better co-op game because up to 3 players can join its local adventure. Each player takes control of one of the three heroes, bringing friends into the action rather than leaving them to watch. That makes the PlayStation 4 edition a natural fit for a shared living-room session.
Square Enix Live A Live Remake is a single-player RPG across its Nintendo Switch, PlayStation and PC editions. The game’s 8 scenarios provide plenty of character variety, but they do not replace multiplayer. For a gift meant for family play or a gaming night, choose Secret of Mana. For a solo player, Live A Live is the stronger story-first choice.
Which remake has the better story and replay value?
Square Enix Live A Live Remake offers more narrative variety, with 8 scenarios that move through distinct settings and time periods. Players experience different protagonists and story styles, then see how the separate chapters fit together. The structure suits anyone who likes compact story arcs rather than one long, continuous plot.
Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake delivers a more traditional fantasy journey with a three-hero party and real-time battles. Its appeal comes from following one adventure and building momentum with the same core cast. Choose Live A Live for changing perspectives and chapter-based discovery; choose Secret of Mana for a straightforward quest and action-focused play.
Which platform should you buy for each RPG?
Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake is listed here for PlayStation 4 and PC, while Square Enix Live A Live Remake is listed for Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5 and PC. Confirm the platform on the product page before checkout, especially when shopping for someone else. A game tied to the wrong system is an avoidable gift miss.
Nintendo Switch is the portable pick for Live A Live, while PlayStation 5 suits players who prefer that console setup. PC versions fit desktop or laptop libraries. Secret of Mana on PlayStation 4 makes a clear couch co-op choice; its PC edition suits computer players. Match the game format and platform to the recipient’s device and play habits.
Which game makes the better Black Friday 2026 gift?
Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake makes the better group gift for players who enjoy action and shared play, while Square Enix Live A Live Remake makes the better solo gift for story-focused RPG fans. The distinction is clear enough to guide a quick purchase: co-op players get more from Mana, and narrative explorers get more from Live A Live.
Before choosing, check whether the recipient prefers handheld, console or PC gaming. Then consider how they spend game time. A player who often hosts friends will value Secret of Mana’s 3-player local co-op. A player who likes varied characters and tactical battles will appreciate Live A Live’s 8 scenarios. Both remakes bring a distinct Square Enix RPG experience.
Buying Guide
Start with combat style
Pick Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for real-time action and movement during battles. Pick Square Enix Live A Live Remake for turn-based encounters where planning and positioning matter. Combat preference is the fastest way to separate these two RPGs.
Check the player count
Secret of Mana supports up to 3 local players, making it the choice for shared play. Live A Live is a 1-player experience built around its 8 stories. Choose the game that fits the recipient’s usual gaming company.
Match the game to the device
Confirm the exact platform before placing an order. Live A Live is available in this guide for Switch, PlayStation and PC; Secret of Mana is listed for PlayStation 4 and PC. Check both the platform label and edition format.
Choose a story structure
Live A Live suits players who like multiple settings and perspectives across 8 scenarios. Secret of Mana follows a central fantasy adventure with 3 heroes. Consider whether the player prefers changing story arcs or one continuous quest.
Think about who will play
For a shared living-room gift, Secret of Mana’s local co-op is the practical fit. For a solo player who enjoys tactical battles and narrative variety, Live A Live is the more targeted choice. The best buy is the one that fits actual play habits.
FAQ
Is Secret of Mana better than Live A Live?
Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake is better for real-time action and local co-op, while Square Enix Live A Live Remake is better for solo story variety. Secret of Mana supports up to 3 local players; Live A Live features 8 separate scenarios.
Does Secret of Mana Remake have co-op?
Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake supports up to 3 players in local co-op. Friends can control the three heroes together during the action RPG adventure. Square Enix Live A Live Remake is a single-player game and does not offer the same co-op format.
How many stories are in Live A Live Remake?
Square Enix Live A Live Remake contains 8 distinct story scenarios. Each scenario introduces its own setting, characters and tone, giving the game more narrative variety than a single continuous quest. The game is designed for one player.
Which game is better for Nintendo Switch?
Square Enix Live A Live Remake for Nintendo Switch is the portable pick in this guide. Its 8 scenarios suit shorter play sessions, and the turn-based combat works well for solo play. Secret of Mana is listed here for PlayStation 4 and PC.
Which game should I buy for Black Friday 2026?
Buy Square Enix Secret of Mana Remake for players who want action and up to 3-player local co-op. Choose Square Enix Live A Live Remake for a solo RPG fan who values 8 story scenarios and turn-based strategy. Confirm the recipient’s platform first.