As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
- Best overall: Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S
- Best budget: MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch
- Best premium: Forza Horizon 5 Premium Edition for Xbox Series X|S
- Best for portable baseball: MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch
- Choose MLB The Show 25 for baseball simulation, team building and a career built around the diamond.
- Choose Forza Horizon 5 for open-world driving, car collecting and a large Mexico-inspired map.
- Forza Horizon 5 offers the widest platform choice across this guide, including Xbox, PC and PlayStation 5 editions.
- Match the game edition to the console you own before choosing a Black Friday 2026 listing.
- The Xbox Wireless Controller and PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller are practical add-ons for compatible setups.
MLB The Show 25 vs Forza Horizon 5 Black Friday 2026 comes down to sports simulation versus open-world racing. I researched and compared specs, reviews and owner feedback to make the choice easier. MLB The Show 25 centers on baseball, with team management, player progression and a range of ways to play. Forza Horizon 5 puts car culture first, pairing free-roaming drives with races and events across a Mexico-inspired setting.
Here’s the bottom line: pick MLB The Show 25 if baseball is the event you want to play, and pick Forza Horizon 5 if you want a big driving playground. The list below covers the key game editions and two compatible controllers. Check the platform and edition name on each listing before checkout; platform support differs across the games. Black Friday 2026 is also a good time to compare bundles and editions against the features you will actually use.
How We Picked
- Compared platform compatibility so every recommendation maps to a specific console or gaming setup.
- Prioritized the core appeal of each game: baseball modes and progression for MLB The Show 25, and open-world driving for Forza Horizon 5.
- Looked at edition differences, including the additional content named for Forza Horizon 5 Premium Edition.
- Reviewed published product specifications, owner feedback and the practical fit for different player types.
- Included controllers as useful gaming accessories, while keeping the game choices central to the comparison.
Comparison Table
| Product | Best for | Platform | Players or cars | Core format |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 | PS5 baseball fans | PlayStation 5 | 1–4 local players | Baseball simulation |
| MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S | Xbox baseball fans | Xbox Series X|S | 1–4 local players | Baseball simulation |
| MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch | Portable baseball | Nintendo Switch | 1–4 local players | Baseball simulation |
| Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S | Xbox racing fans | Xbox Series X|S | More than 500 cars | Open-world racing |
| Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 | PS5 racing fans | PlayStation 5 | More than 500 cars | Open-world racing |
| Forza Horizon 5 Premium Edition for Xbox Series X|S | Xbox players seeking add-ons | Xbox Series X|S | More than 500 cars | Expanded open-world racing |
| Xbox Wireless Controller | Xbox gamepad upgrade | Xbox Series X|S | 2 wireless options | Game controller |
| PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller | PS5 gamepad upgrade | PlayStation 5 | 2 signature features | Game controller |
Best Picks Reviewed
#1
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5
The MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is the best baseball pick for PS5 owners who want a current-generation diamond experience, with support for 1–4 local players.
Best for: PS5 players who prefer baseball simulation
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- Local players
- 1–4
- Edition
- Standard Edition
- Focused baseball gameplay and team progression
- A straightforward pick for PS5 owners
- Local multiplayer supports up to 4 players
- Only suits players with a PlayStation 5
- Not a racing game or general sports collection
Is MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is worth considering for PS5 owners who want baseball, player progression and local play for up to 4 people. Choose it over Forza Horizon 5 when the diamond is the main draw.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#2
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S
The MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S is the best baseball option for Xbox players who want a dedicated sports sim, with local play for 1–4 players.
Best for: Xbox owners who want baseball gameplay
- Platform
- Xbox Series X|S
- Local players
- 1–4
- Edition
- Standard Edition
- Baseball-focused modes and progression
- Works across the Xbox Series X|S console family
- Up to 4 local players
- Requires an Xbox Series X or Series S
- The MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S's sports focus is narrower than an open-world game
Is MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S is a strong fit for Xbox owners who want baseball simulation and local multiplayer for up to 4 players. The MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S is the better match than Forza Horizon 5 for fans of batting, pitching and team play.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#3
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch
The MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch is the best portable baseball pick for players who want the series away from a TV, with 1–4 local players supported.
Best for: Portable baseball and Nintendo Switch owners
- Platform
- Nintendo Switch
- Local players
- 1–4
- Edition
- Standard Edition
- Portable access to baseball gameplay
- Supports local play for up to 4 players
- Fits a Nintendo-focused setup
- Not the right option for PS5 or Xbox owners
- Forza Horizon 5 is the better fit for racing fans
Is MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch is worth a look for players who value portable baseball and local matches for up to 4 people. Check that the Nintendo Switch version matches your console before choosing it.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#4 · Top pick
Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S
The Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S is the best open-world racing pick for Xbox owners, with a garage featuring more than 500 cars.
Best for: Xbox players who want open-world racing
- Platform
- Xbox Series X|S
- Cars
- More than 500
- Setting
- Mexico-inspired open world
- Large vehicle collection
- Free-roaming drives alongside structured events
- A strong contrast to baseball simulation
- Requires an Xbox Series X or Series S
- Not a sports game for baseball fans
Is Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X|S is a solid choice for Xbox players who want open-world driving and a collection of more than 500 cars. Choose it over MLB The Show 25 when racing and exploration sound more fun.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#5
Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5
The Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is the best way for PS5 owners to explore this open-world racer, with more than 500 cars to collect and drive.
Best for: PS5 players looking for a racing game
- Platform
- PlayStation 5
- Cars
- More than 500
- Edition
- Standard Edition
- Brings the Forza Horizon racing series to PS5
- Large selection of cars
- Open-world exploration and event variety
- Does not include the Premium Edition add-ons
- Only fits players seeking a driving game
Is Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is a good fit for PS5 owners who want open-world racing, exploration and more than 500 cars. The Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 offers a different kind of play from MLB The Show 25, so choose by genre first.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#6
Forza Horizon 5 Premium Edition for Xbox Series X|S
The Forza Horizon 5 Premium Edition for Xbox Series X|S is the best expanded racing bundle for Xbox players who want extra included content alongside a garage of more than 500 cars.
Best for: Xbox racers who want additional game content
- Platform
- Xbox Series X|S
- Cars
- More than 500
- Edition
- Premium Edition
- Included content
- Additional add-ons
- Expanded edition for committed racers
- Includes additional content beyond the standard edition
- Large car collection and open-world activities
- Extra content is less useful for casual players
- Confirm the included add-ons on the specific listing
Is Forza Horizon 5 Premium Edition for Xbox Series X|S worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Forza Horizon 5 Premium Edition for Xbox Series X|S suits Xbox players who want the base racing game plus additional included content. Compare its listed add-ons with the Standard Edition before choosing, especially if you mainly want the core driving experience.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#7
Xbox Wireless Controller
The Xbox Wireless Controller is the best accessory pick for Xbox owners who want a familiar gamepad for MLB The Show 25 or Forza Horizon 5, with 2 wireless connection options.
Best for: Xbox players who need a versatile gamepad
- Wireless connections
- 2: Xbox Wireless and Bluetooth
- Compatible console family
- Xbox Series X|S
- Battery type
- 2 AA batteries
- Works for sports and racing games
- Bluetooth supports compatible devices
- Familiar layout for Xbox players
- Not the native controller for PS5
- AA batteries are separate from built-in rechargeable packs
Is the Xbox Wireless Controller worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
The Xbox Wireless Controller is worth considering for Xbox owners who want one gamepad for both MLB The Show 25 and Forza Horizon 5. The Xbox Wireless Controller's 2 wireless connection options also make it useful with compatible Bluetooth devices.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#8
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller
The PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller is the best accessory pick for PS5 players choosing MLB The Show 25 or Forza Horizon 5, with 2 signature features: haptic feedback and adaptive triggers.
Best for: PS5 players who want a second controller
- Compatible console
- PlayStation 5
- Signature features
- 2: haptic feedback and adaptive triggers
- Connection
- Wireless
- Designed for PS5 games
- Haptic feedback adds tactile cues
- Adaptive triggers support varied resistance
- Not the native gamepad for Xbox consoles
- Feature support varies by game
Is the PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
The PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller is a useful pick for PS5 owners who want a spare or replacement gamepad. Haptic feedback and adaptive triggers add two distinctive features, while compatibility with individual game features varies.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
Which is better, MLB The Show 25 or Forza Horizon 5?
Choose MLB The Show 25 for baseball, or Forza Horizon 5 for open-world racing and exploration.
MLB The Show 25 focuses on baseball and supports 1–4 local players. Forza Horizon 5 features a Mexico-inspired driving world and more than 500 cars, with races and exploration for players who prefer driving to baseball.
Which platforms support MLB The Show 25 and Forza Horizon 5?
MLB The Show 25 is available for PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S and Nintendo Switch. Forza Horizon 5 is listed here for PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S. Confirm the platform before buying for Black Friday 2026.
Check the complete product listing, since similar titles can refer to different console editions. Match the Xbox Wireless Controller to an Xbox console and the PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller to a PS5.
Should I choose a standard or Premium Edition?
Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition includes the core racing game and access to more than 500 cars. Forza Horizon 5 Premium Edition adds extra content for players seeking a broader package.
Review the listing for its included add-ons. The MLB The Show 25 products in this guide are Standard Editions; choose the platform that matches your console.
Which game is better for multiplayer and playing with friends?
MLB The Show 25 supports 1–4 local players, making it a clear choice for group baseball sessions. Check the platform edition and have enough compatible controllers.
Choose Forza Horizon 5 for races and exploration in a large driving world. Multiplayer availability depends on platform, account and game settings, so check the details for your setup.
What should I look for in a Black Friday 2026 game listing?
Check the platform, edition, format and included content. MLB The Show 25 listings cover PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S and Nintendo Switch; Forza Horizon 5 listings include Standard Edition and Xbox Series X|S Premium Edition.
Review seller and compatibility details, and match any controller to your console. Compare included content with what you plan to play.
Buying Guide
Start with your console
Match the listing to PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S or Nintendo Switch. Editions are not interchangeable across console families.
Pick the genre you will play
Choose MLB The Show 25 for baseball or Forza Horizon 5 for open-world racing and a collection of more than 500 cars.
Compare editions
Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition includes the core game; Forza Horizon 5 Premium Edition includes extra content. Check the listing for details.
Plan for group sessions
MLB The Show 25 supports 1–4 local players. Check play options and controller requirements for your platform.
Check the listing details
Confirm the edition, platform, format and seller. Pair the Xbox Wireless Controller with Xbox or the PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller with PS5.
FAQ
Is MLB The Show 25 or Forza Horizon 5 better for Black Friday 2026?
MLB The Show 25 is better for players who want baseball simulation, while Forza Horizon 5 is better for open-world racing and exploration. Choose by genre first, then confirm the edition matches your console.
Can I play MLB The Show 25 on Nintendo Switch?
Yes, MLB The Show 25 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch is the portable baseball option in this guide. Confirm that the listing names Nintendo Switch as its platform before buying, since other editions are for different consoles.
Is Forza Horizon 5 available for PS5?
Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is included as a PS5 option in this guide. The Xbox Premium Edition is a separate product, so check the platform and edition details carefully when comparing listings.
What is the difference between Forza Horizon 5 Standard and Premium Edition?
Forza Horizon 5 Standard Edition provides the core open-world racing game. Forza Horizon 5 Premium Edition includes additional content beyond the base game. Review the listing’s included-content description to see exactly what comes with the edition.
Which game supports local multiplayer?
MLB The Show 25 lists local play for 1–4 players, making it a clear choice for a shared baseball session. Forza Horizon 5 focuses on open-world driving; check its platform-specific multiplayer details for your preferred way to play.
Which controller should I buy for these games?
Choose the Xbox Wireless Controller for an Xbox Series X|S setup and the PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller for PS5. Each is designed for its console family, so match the controller to the hardware before purchasing.