As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
- Best overall: 505 Games Terraria on Steam for PC
- Best budget: Toby Fox Undertale on Steam for PC
- Best premium: 505 Games Terraria for Nintendo Switch
- Best for handheld play: Toby Fox Undertale for Nintendo Switch
- Undertale is a compact, story-focused RPG with one-player gameplay and meaningful choices.
- Terraria is a sprawling 2D sandbox built around exploration, crafting and combat.
- The best pick depends on whether you want a narrative adventure or an open-ended world.
- Choose the platform you already use to keep your game library and multiplayer plans simple.
Undertale and Terraria offer two very different kinds of gaming, so the best Black Friday 2026 pick comes down to story versus sandbox freedom. Undertale puts one player in a character-driven RPG with three major routes. Terraria gives players a 2D world to explore, build and fight through, with four character classes shaping combat.
I researched and compared specs, reviews and owner feedback across the available PC and console versions. Here's the bottom line: choose Undertale for a memorable, focused story, or Terraria for long-running crafting and exploration. The picks below identify the right version for each platform, plus practical advice for choosing between these very different games.
How We Picked
- Compared each game's core appeal, including Undertale's story and choices versus Terraria's building, exploration and combat.
- Included versions for popular platforms so readers can match a purchase to the system they already own.
- Reviewed platform features and owner feedback, prioritizing clear information over claims about a specific sale price.
- Considered replay value, multiplayer options where applicable and the kind of play session each game supports.
- Selected distinct picks for PC, console and portable play rather than treating every edition as interchangeable.
Comparison Table
| Product | Best for | Platform | Players | Core gameplay |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Toby Fox Undertale for Nintendo Switch | Handheld story-RPG fans | Nintendo Switch | 1 player | 3 main routes |
| Toby Fox Undertale for PlayStation 4 | PS4 owners who prefer narrative games | PlayStation 4 | 1 player | 3 main routes |
| Toby Fox Undertale on Steam for PC | PC players who want a story-led RPG | PC via Steam | 1 player | 3 main routes |
| 505 Games Terraria for Nintendo Switch | Portable sandbox and crafting fans | Nintendo Switch | 1 player locally | 4 character classes |
| 505 Games Terraria for PlayStation 4 | PS4 players who enjoy building and combat | PlayStation 4 | 1 player locally | 4 character classes |
| 505 Games Terraria for Xbox One | Xbox One owners who want a long-form sandbox | Xbox One | 1 player locally | 4 character classes |
| 505 Games Terraria on Steam for PC | PC sandbox fans | PC via Steam | 1 player | 4 character classes |
Undertale vs Terraria Black Friday Deals 2026
#1
Toby Fox Undertale for Nintendo Switch
The Toby Fox Undertale for Nintendo Switch is the best story RPG for handheld players who want a focused adventure with three major routes. The portable format suits short sessions while preserving the game's choices, characters and distinctive humor.
Best for: Handheld story-RPG fans
- Platform
- Nintendo Switch
- Players
- 1 player
- Main routes
- 3
- Genre
- 2D role-playing game
- Portable play fits quick sessions.
- Three routes encourage replaying with different choices.
- Distinctive characters and music give the story a strong identity.
- Single-player only; no sandbox building or multiplayer.
Is the Toby Fox Undertale for Nintendo Switch worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. Toby Fox Undertale for Nintendo Switch is a strong pick for players who want a portable, one-player RPG with three major routes and a memorable story. Choose this version when playing away from a television matters.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#2
Toby Fox Undertale for PlayStation 4
The Toby Fox Undertale for PlayStation 4 is the best console story pick for PS4 owners who want a one-player RPG with three major routes. The Toby Fox Undertale for PlayStation 4's focused adventure puts character choices and encounters ahead of crafting or open-world progression.
Best for: PS4 owners who prefer narrative games
- Platform
- PlayStation 4
- Players
- 1 player
- Main routes
- 3
- Genre
- 2D role-playing game
- A natural fit for an existing PS4 library.
- Story decisions make repeat playthroughs distinct.
- Simple controls keep attention on encounters and dialogue.
- Not the pick for co-op or open-ended crafting.
Is the Toby Fox Undertale for PlayStation 4 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. Toby Fox Undertale for PlayStation 4 suits PS4 players seeking a complete, single-player story adventure with three major routes. The game prioritizes character interactions and choices, making it a better fit for narrative fans than sandbox builders.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#3
Toby Fox Undertale on Steam for PC
The Toby Fox Undertale on Steam for PC is the best PC pick for players who want a compact RPG with three major routes and keyboard-and-controller flexibility. The one-player design keeps the focus on story, choices and unusual combat encounters.
Best for: PC players who want a story-led RPG
- Platform
- PC via Steam
- Players
- 1 player
- Main routes
- 3
- Genre
- 2D role-playing game
- A good match for an existing PC game library.
- Controller and keyboard play support different setups.
- Three main routes give the story replay value.
- Solo gameplay offers no cooperative mode.
Is the Toby Fox Undertale on Steam for PC worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. Toby Fox Undertale on Steam for PC is a worthwhile choice for players who want a one-player RPG with three major routes. Pick the PC version for a flexible desk setup and a focused story rather than multiplayer or extensive crafting.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#4
505 Games Terraria for Nintendo Switch
The 505 Games Terraria for Nintendo Switch is the best portable sandbox for players who want 2D exploration, crafting and combat in one game. Four character classes support different combat styles, while handheld play makes world-building easy to take along.
Best for: Portable sandbox and crafting fans
- Platform
- Nintendo Switch
- Players
- 1 player locally
- Character classes
- 4
- Genre
- 2D sandbox adventure
- Handheld play works well for exploration in short bursts.
- Four classes offer varied approaches to combat.
- Building and crafting give the world long-term replay value.
- The many crafting and progression systems take time to learn.
Is the 505 Games Terraria for Nintendo Switch worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. 505 Games Terraria for Nintendo Switch is a strong choice for portable players who enjoy crafting, combat and exploration. Four character classes add variety, and the handheld format lets players continue building without staying beside a television.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#5
505 Games Terraria for PlayStation 4
The 505 Games Terraria for PlayStation 4 is the best couch-console sandbox for PS4 players who want 2D exploration and four combat classes. The open-ended mix of mining, crafting, building and boss fights supports longer play sessions and shared adventures.
Best for: PS4 players who enjoy building and combat
- Platform
- PlayStation 4
- Players
- 1 player locally
- Character classes
- 4
- Genre
- 2D sandbox adventure
- A deep world rewards exploration and experimentation.
- Four classes give combat clear play-style options.
- Building projects add goals beyond fighting bosses.
- Progression has more systems to learn than a short story game.
Is the 505 Games Terraria for PlayStation 4 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. 505 Games Terraria for PlayStation 4 fits PS4 owners who want an open-ended game with building, exploration and combat. Four classes help vary encounters, while the wide range of crafting goals makes the adventure a better match for players who enjoy gradual progression.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#6
505 Games Terraria for Xbox One
The 505 Games Terraria for Xbox One is the best Xbox sandbox pick for players who want a 2D adventure with four character classes. Mining, crafting and boss fights give the game a broad progression loop beyond its colorful world.
Best for: Xbox One owners who want a long-form sandbox
- Platform
- Xbox One
- Players
- 1 player locally
- Character classes
- 4
- Genre
- 2D sandbox adventure
- A clear fit for an Xbox One library.
- Four classes offer different combat approaches.
- Exploration and crafting support varied goals.
- The open-ended structure has less guided storytelling than Undertale.
Is the 505 Games Terraria for Xbox One worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. 505 Games Terraria for Xbox One is a good match for Xbox players who want a large sandbox built around crafting and combat. Four classes add variety, but the open-ended structure favors players who enjoy setting their own goals over following a tightly guided story.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
#7 · Top pick
505 Games Terraria on Steam for PC
The 505 Games Terraria on Steam for PC is the best all-around sandbox pick for PC players who want 2D building, exploration and four combat classes. The PC version is a natural choice for players who prefer a mouse-and-keyboard setup and an established Steam library.
Best for: PC sandbox fans
- Platform
- PC via Steam
- Players
- 1 player
- Character classes
- 4
- Genre
- 2D sandbox adventure
- A strong fit for PC players who enjoy long-term progression.
- Four classes support distinct combat approaches.
- Mining, crafting and building keep goals varied.
- The large range of systems can feel busy at first.
Is the 505 Games Terraria on Steam for PC worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. 505 Games Terraria on Steam for PC is a strong pick for players seeking an open-ended sandbox with four character classes. The PC edition suits players who favor a desktop setup and want exploration, crafting and combat to anchor extended play.
See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon
Is Undertale or Terraria better for Black Friday 2026?
Undertale suits story-first players, while Terraria suits sandbox fans who want more than one way to spend a session. Undertale delivers a focused RPG with one player and three major routes. Terraria centers on exploration, crafting and combat, with four classes offering different combat styles.
Choose based on what you want to do after starting the game. Players who value dialogue, character moments and a compact narrative should start with Undertale. Players who want to mine, build, explore and set personal goals should choose Terraria. Both games stand out for very different reasons, so platform convenience and play style matter more than matching genres.
What is the difference between Undertale and Terraria?
Undertale is a one-player story RPG with three major routes, while Terraria is a 2D sandbox adventure with four character classes. The difference shapes the whole experience: Undertale guides players through encounters and story choices, while Terraria gives players a world to explore and tools to shape it.
Undertale is the clearer match for a shorter, character-led journey. Terraria is the better fit for players who enjoy crafting chains, equipment progression and building projects. Neither game is a direct substitute for the other. Pick by deciding whether a memorable plot or an open-ended world sounds more appealing.
Which Undertale platform should you choose?
Toby Fox Undertale for Nintendo Switch is the portable pick, while the PlayStation 4 and Steam for PC versions suit existing console and computer libraries. All three options preserve the game's single-player, story-led identity and three major routes.
For travel and handheld sessions, choose the Nintendo Switch version. PS4 owners who prefer a television setup can choose the PlayStation 4 edition. PC players should select the Steam version for a familiar desktop library and keyboard or controller play. The story remains the main reason to buy, so match the version to the device you use most.
Which Terraria platform is best for your setup?
505 Games Terraria on Steam for PC is the broad PC pick, while Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One editions suit players already invested in those systems. Every version centers on the sandbox loop: explore, gather materials, craft gear and take on tougher encounters.
Choose Nintendo Switch when handheld access matters. Select PlayStation 4 or Xbox One to stay with a living-room console library. PC players should look at the Steam edition, especially when a desktop setup is already part of their routine. Terraria has many systems to learn, so platform familiarity helps make its open-ended progression easier to settle into.
Should you buy Undertale or Terraria as a gift?
Undertale is the safer gift for players who enjoy stories, while Terraria fits recipients who like crafting and self-directed goals. Undertale's one-player structure makes it a straightforward solo pick, and its three routes give story fans a reason to revisit the game.
Terraria is a better gift for someone who enjoys collecting materials, building and changing tactics across four classes. Check the recipient's platform before choosing either game; a console edition should match the system they own, while a Steam edition belongs with their PC library. If their tastes are unclear, use their favorite kind of play session as the deciding clue.
Buying Guide
Choose story or sandbox first
Undertale is the story pick, with 1-player gameplay and 3 major routes. Terraria is the sandbox pick, built around exploration, crafting and combat. Decide which loop sounds fun before comparing editions.
Match the game to your platform
Toby Fox Undertale for Nintendo Switch suits handheld play, while its PS4 and Steam for PC versions fit those libraries. 505 Games Terraria is available across Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Xbox One and Steam for PC in this guide.
Consider the learning curve
Undertale keeps attention on its story and encounters. Terraria has 4 character classes alongside mining, crafting and building systems. Choose Undertale for a more guided journey or Terraria for a world that rewards experimentation.
Think about who will play
Undertale's listed versions are single-player picks. Terraria's versions also support solo play, with multiplayer features depending on platform and setup. Confirm the recipient's system and preferred way to play before selecting an edition.
Use Black Friday to compare editions
Compare the exact platform version, not just the game title. Check the listing's edition details and compatibility with your console or PC library. Choose the version that fits your setup and the kind of game you want to revisit.
FAQ
Is Undertale better than Terraria for a first-time player?
Undertale is the better starting point for players who want a guided story and one-player adventure. Terraria suits players comfortable learning several connected systems, including crafting, exploration and combat. Choose by preferred play style rather than difficulty alone.
Is Terraria worth buying on Black Friday 2026?
Yes. Terraria is a strong pick for players who want a 2D world built around exploration, crafting and combat. Four character classes support different approaches to fights, and the open-ended structure gives players room to pursue personal building and progression goals.
Does Undertale have multiple endings?
Yes. Undertale has three major routes shaped by player choices and actions. The route structure gives story-focused players reasons to revisit the game, though Undertale remains a single-player RPG rather than a multiplayer or open-world sandbox experience.
Can you play Terraria solo?
Yes. Terraria supports solo play, so players can explore, build and fight without joining a group. The game also has multiplayer features, with details varying by platform and setup. Check the edition and system requirements that match your device.
Which game has more replay value, Undertale or Terraria?
Terraria offers broader open-ended replay through exploration, crafting, building and four character classes. Undertale offers replay through its three major routes and story choices. Terraria fits players who want ongoing world goals, while Undertale suits players revisiting a narrative.
Which Undertale version should I buy on Black Friday 2026?
Choose Toby Fox Undertale for Nintendo Switch for portable play, Toby Fox Undertale for PlayStation 4 for a PS4 library, or Toby Fox Undertale on Steam for PC for a desktop setup. The best version is the one that matches the system you use.