WWE 2K24 vs MLB The Show 24 Black Friday 2026: Top Offers

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

WWE 2K24 and MLB The Show 24 are very different sports games, so the right Black Friday 2026 pick depends on what you want to play. WWE 2K24 centers on wrestling, signature match types, and a Showcase built around 40 Years of WrestleMania. MLB The Show 24 focuses on baseball, team management, season play, and the Road to the Show career.

I researched and compared specs, reviews and owner feedback to build a platform-by-platform shortlist, including console versions and useful controllers. Check that each edition matches your system before choosing. Here's the bottom line: baseball fans should start with MLB The Show 24, while wrestling fans should start with WWE 2K24. The picks below make it easier to find the right fit for PlayStation, Xbox, or Switch.

How We Picked

• Compared each game’s platform compatibility so the shortlist covers PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S, and Nintendo Switch where available.
• Reviewed signature modes and features, including WWE 2K24’s WrestleMania Showcase and MLB The Show 24’s baseball career and season options.
• Considered the type of player each edition serves, from portable Switch play to a home-console sports setup.
• Researched and compared specs, reviews and owner feedback rather than relying on a single feature or rating.
• Included first-party controllers as practical add-ons for players building a complete console setup.

Comparison Table

Product	Best for	Platform	Signature feature	Best for
2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5	PS5 wrestling fans	PlayStation 5	40 Years of WrestleMania	Wrestling matches
2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X	Xbox wrestling fans	Xbox Series X|S	40 Years of WrestleMania	Wrestling matches
Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5	PS5 baseball fans	PlayStation 5	30 MLB teams	Career and season play
Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X	Xbox baseball fans	Xbox Series X|S	30 MLB teams	Career and season play
Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch	Portable baseball fans	Nintendo Switch	30 MLB teams	Portable career play
Sony DualSense Wireless Controller for PlayStation 5	PS5 controller add-on	PlayStation 5	2 haptic actuators	Sports and wrestling
Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series X|S	Xbox controller add-on	Xbox Series X|S	2 analog sticks	Sports and wrestling

Best Picks Reviewed

#1

2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5

The 2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is the best wrestling game pick for PS5 owners who want a large roster and a story-driven Showcase. The 2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5's signature mode celebrates 40 Years of WrestleMania.

Best for: PS5 players who prefer wrestling and Showcase matches

Platform

PlayStation 5

Showcase theme

40 Years of WrestleMania

Roster size

200+ Superstars

Pros

• Wrestling-focused match variety
• Showcase pairs matches with WrestleMania history
• Designed for PS5

Cons

• Not a baseball game
• Not available for Nintendo Switch

Is the 2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?

Yes. The 2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is a strong Black Friday pick for wrestling fans who own a PS5. The 40 Years of WrestleMania Showcase and 200+ Superstar roster give players plenty of wrestling-focused content.

Check Price on Amazon

See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon

#2

2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X

The 2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X is the best wrestling game pick for Xbox owners who want a broad roster and classic matchups. The game features a 40 Years of WrestleMania Showcase.

Best for: Xbox Series X|S players who want wrestling action

Platform

Xbox Series X|S

Showcase theme

40 Years of WrestleMania

Roster size

200+ Superstars

Pros

• Wrestling matches and signature rivalries
• Multiple modes beyond Showcase
• Xbox console edition

Cons

• No baseball gameplay
• Not a portable console edition

Is the 2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X worth buying on Black Friday 2026?

Yes. The 2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X fits Xbox players who want wrestling matches, a large Superstar roster, and a WrestleMania-centered Showcase. Confirm the Xbox edition matches your console before buying.

Check Price on Amazon

See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon

#3 · Top pick

Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5

The Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is the best overall baseball pick for PS5 players who want major-league teams and career modes. The game features all 30 MLB teams.

Best for: PS5 baseball fans who want varied career and season play

Platform

PlayStation 5

MLB teams

30

Featured career mode

Road to the Show

Pros

• Authentic MLB team and player focus
• Career and season modes
• Baseball-first gameplay

Cons

• Not a wrestling game
• Requires a PlayStation console

Is the Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?

Yes. The Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for PlayStation 5 is a solid pick for PS5 owners who want baseball, 30 MLB teams, and a player career. Select it over WWE 2K24 when baseball is the priority.

Check Price on Amazon

See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon

#4

Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X

The Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X is the best baseball pick for Xbox players who want MLB teams and career progression. The Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X's lineup covers all 30 MLB teams.

Best for: Xbox owners who want MLB season and career gameplay

Platform

Xbox Series X|S

MLB teams

30

Featured career mode

Road to the Show

Pros

• Baseball roster and team focus
• Career progression option
• Xbox console edition

Cons

• No wrestling modes
• Not the portable edition

Is the Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X worth buying on Black Friday 2026?

Yes. The Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X suits Xbox players who want baseball, 30 MLB teams, and Road to the Show. Match the edition to your Xbox before placing an order.

Check Price on Amazon

See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon

#5

Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch

The Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch is the best portable baseball pick for players who want MLB gameplay away from a TV. The game includes all 30 MLB teams.

Best for: Players who want baseball on a portable console

Platform

Nintendo Switch

MLB teams

30

Featured career mode

Road to the Show

Pros

• Portable baseball play
• A distinct option from wrestling games
• Career mode supports ongoing progression

Cons

• Not a PlayStation or Xbox edition
• No WWE wrestling content

Is the Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch worth buying on Black Friday 2026?

Yes. The Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch is the clearest choice for portable baseball. The 30-team MLB focus and Road to the Show career make it a better fit for baseball fans than WWE 2K24.

Check Price on Amazon

See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon

#6

Sony DualSense Wireless Controller for PlayStation 5

The Sony DualSense Wireless Controller for PlayStation 5 is the best controller add-on for PS5 players who want precise inputs and immersive feedback. The controller includes 2 built-in haptic feedback actuators.

Best for: PS5 players replacing or adding a controller

Compatible console

PlayStation 5

Haptic actuators

2

Analog sticks

2

Pros

• Built for PS5
• Haptic feedback and adaptive triggers
• Useful for sports and wrestling games

Cons

• Not the Xbox or Switch controller
• Requires charging between sessions

Is the Sony DualSense Wireless Controller for PlayStation 5 worth buying on Black Friday 2026?

Yes. The Sony DualSense Wireless Controller for PlayStation 5 is a useful companion for PS5 versions of WWE 2K24 and MLB The Show 24. The Sony DualSense Wireless Controller for PlayStation 5's haptic feedback and adaptive triggers add console-specific input features for compatible games.

Check Price on Amazon

See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon

#7

Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series X|S

The Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series X|S is the best controller add-on for Xbox players who want a familiar layout and broad compatibility. The controller has 2 analog sticks and a dedicated Share button.

Best for: Xbox players adding a second controller

Compatible consoles

Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One

Analog sticks

2

Share button

1

Pros

• Works with Xbox Series X|S
• Dedicated Share button
• Useful for sports and wrestling games

Cons

• Not the PS5 or Switch controller
• Uses replaceable batteries or a rechargeable pack

Is the Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series X|S worth buying on Black Friday 2026?

Yes. The Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series X|S is a practical add-on for Xbox owners playing either featured game. The 2-stick layout and Share button make it suitable for everyday play and sharing gameplay clips.

Check Price on Amazon

See today’s Black Friday price on Amazon

Which is better, WWE 2K24 or MLB The Show 24?

WWE 2K24 is the better choice for wrestling fans, while MLB The Show 24 is the better choice for baseball fans. WWE 2K24 centers on Superstar matchups, signature bouts, and a Showcase celebrating 40 Years of WrestleMania. MLB The Show 24 instead offers baseball teams, season play, and Road to the Show career progression.

The games do not compete on the same sport, so choose by the gameplay you want to return to. Players who enjoy building a career around one created athlete should look at MLB The Show 24. Players who want fantasy matchups and wrestling spectacle should look at WWE 2K24. Both games suit fans who already own a compatible console.

Which platforms support WWE 2K24 and MLB The Show 24?

WWE 2K24 has PlayStation and Xbox editions, while MLB The Show 24 also has a Nintendo Switch edition. Confirm the platform printed on the product listing: game editions are not interchangeable across console families.

For PlayStation 5, the shortlist includes both WWE 2K24 and MLB The Show 24. Xbox Series X|S players can choose between both games as well. Nintendo Switch owners looking for one of these two sports titles should choose MLB The Show 24. Match physical media to your console’s disc support, and check the edition details before checkout.

Is MLB The Show 24 on Nintendo Switch a good Black Friday pick?

MLB The Show 24 for Nintendo Switch is the portable pick for baseball fans who want to play away from a television. The Switch version keeps the game’s baseball focus and includes 30 MLB teams, making it the clear choice in this guide for on-the-go play.

Choose the Switch edition when portability matters more than playing on a home console. Choose a PS5 or Xbox edition when that is where you play most often. The Nintendo Switch version is not a WWE 2K24 alternative: the two games cover different sports, and WWE 2K24 is not included in this Switch shortlist.

What makes WWE 2K24 worth considering?

WWE 2K24 stands out for wrestling fans with its 40 Years of WrestleMania Showcase and roster of more than 200 Superstars. The Showcase gives players a structured route through marquee moments, while other modes support different ways to build matches and play.

Choose WWE 2K24 if you want wrestling as the main event rather than baseball simulation. PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S versions suit players on those consoles. The right edition is the one that matches your system, preferred format, and interest in wrestling modes.

What should I check before buying a Black Friday game?

Check the console platform, edition name, and physical or digital format before buying any Black Friday game. A listing for PlayStation 5 does not serve an Xbox or Switch owner, even when the game title is the same.

Next, compare the modes that matter to you. MLB The Show 24 is the baseball option, with 30 MLB teams and Road to the Show. WWE 2K24 is the wrestling option, with a Showcase celebrating 40 Years of WrestleMania. For a controller add-on, choose Sony DualSense for PS5 or Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series X|S.

Buying Guide

Start with your sport

Pick MLB The Show 24 for baseball, MLB teams, and Road to the Show. Pick WWE 2K24 for wrestling, Superstar matchups, and its WrestleMania Showcase. Sport preference is the fastest way to narrow the shortlist.

Match the game to your console

Select PlayStation 5 or Xbox Series X|S editions for those systems. Choose the Nintendo Switch edition of MLB The Show 24 for portable baseball. Verify the platform on the listing before ordering.

Choose the right edition format

Check whether the listing is for a physical game or a digital version. Confirm that your console supports the chosen format, then review the included edition and content details.

Compare modes, not just names

MLB The Show 24 centers on baseball, 30 MLB teams, and career play. WWE 2K24 centers on wrestling and a 40 Years of WrestleMania Showcase. Choose the gameplay loop you want.

Add a matching controller

Pair a PS5 game with the Sony DualSense Wireless Controller for PlayStation 5, or choose the Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series X|S. A platform-matched controller keeps the setup simple.

FAQ

Which game should I buy on Black Friday 2026, WWE 2K24 or MLB The Show 24?

Choose WWE 2K24 if wrestling matches and its 40 Years of WrestleMania Showcase appeal most. Choose MLB The Show 24 if you want baseball, 30 MLB teams, and career play. Your preferred sport matters more than a direct feature comparison.

Is MLB The Show 24 available on Nintendo Switch?

Yes. Sony Interactive Entertainment MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition for Nintendo Switch is the portable baseball option in this guide. The game includes 30 MLB teams and Road to the Show. Check that the product listing names Nintendo Switch.

Can I play WWE 2K24 on Xbox Series X?

Yes. 2K WWE 2K24 Standard Edition for Xbox Series X is the Xbox console version listed here. The game features wrestling modes and a Showcase centered on 40 Years of WrestleMania. Confirm the edition matches your Xbox console.

Which game has more baseball teams?

MLB The Show 24 is the baseball game in this comparison and features all 30 MLB teams. WWE 2K24 focuses on professional wrestling rather than baseball, so it is not a team-based MLB alternative.

Which controller should I choose for these games?

Choose the Sony DualSense Wireless Controller for PlayStation 5 when playing on PS5. Choose the Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series X|S on Xbox. Pick a controller that matches the console you own.

Is WWE 2K24 better than MLB The Show 24 for single-player play?

Both games offer solo play, but they serve different interests. WWE 2K24 is the wrestling pick, while MLB The Show 24 offers baseball career and season options. Choose based on whether you prefer wrestling matchups or baseball progression.